Gothic 4 — Arcania:

Arcania: Gothic 4 – A Beautiful but Hollow Successor Released in 2010, remains one of the most controversial entries in the legendary Gothic franchise. Developed by Spellbound Entertainment instead of the original series creators, Piranha Bytes, it attempted to modernize the notoriously difficult series for a broader audience. The result is a game that split the community down the middle: a visually stunning fantasy adventure for some, and a "dumbed-down" disappointment for others. The Visual High Point

Even years after its release, critics agree that . ArcaniA: Gothic 4 | Various Thoughts - Offkorn.com Arcania: Gothic 4