You can find more detailed discussions and fan reactions on the Episode Reddit Thread or read a full scene-by-scene breakdown at TV Fanatic .
: Karl attempts to paint a portrait of Gail , telling her she is a "natural." However, hidden in his paint box are knives he intends to use to kill her. [S4E10] Paint Misbehavin'
: The rest of the gang remains preoccupied with finding Jasper, who has disappeared from the group. Cast & Characters Will Forte Tandy (Phil Miller) Mel Rodriguez Todd Rodriguez Mary Steenburgen Gail Klosterman Fred Armisen Karl Cowperthwaite January Jones Melissa Shart Kristen Schaal Carol Pilbasian You can find more detailed discussions and fan
: While looking at his reflection in a knife, Karl suffers a psychological break, begins crying, and flees the room. Cast & Characters Will Forte Tandy (Phil Miller)
: Tandy and Todd follow Karl to a cemetery, where they witness him digging up a grave and eating a corpse—revealing his cannibalistic nature.