Jay officially breaks up with Lola and begins a new relationship with Matthew, which is widely cited by reviewers as a positive, healthy development for Jay's character.
The "Nick being an ass" storyline was polarizing, with some fans feeling his redemption came slightly late after a season of frustrating behavior. Hate Worm to Lovebug Missy turns Rochelle into a lovebug. New Couple Jay and Matthew. Meta Cameo Live-action Nick Kroll appears as himself. Backdoor Pilot [S5E10] Re-New Year's Eve
The episode revolves around a New Year's Eve party where the main characters attempt "grand gestures" to resolve the season's conflicts. Jay officially breaks up with Lola and begins
Some viewers on Reddit felt the season leaned into "drama for drama's sake" and that certain supporting characters, like the parents and Duke, were underutilized. New Couple Jay and Matthew
The long-running mystery sees a minor breakthrough when the killer makes an on-screen appearance (partially) during a car accident, though the victim who knows his identity is killed before he can speak. Critical Review & Reception
The episode received generally positive reviews for its ambition and character growth, though some fans found the season as a whole slightly less impactful than previous ones.